Dear NYC on 9/11/01,
I tried to watch you on Dateline last night, hoping, as I do every year, that maybe I can actually get through a segment. Alas, I failed.
I do understand the honor required with remembrance. But, why does everyone in the world want a piece of you? Why do people feel the need to continue rehashing this solvent event and replaying it over and over? I think it’s because everyone wants to mourn you, and sympathize, and be a part of you even if just for a conversation.
I suppose it happened to all of us. But, unless you were there, I cannot imagine you know. I will never, ever be able to explain my experience with you that day. Not in writing, not in speaking. It’s my secret. It’s the similar concept of not fully understanding grief until you experience it first-hand. Many just won’t understand how complex emotional failure can be. Many just don’t understand how your nerves feel the terror and process it and make you keep walking forward despite the pain and fear.
Your streets were dusty and grey and you smelled awful and all of the people dying in the air above your feet… I was with you for it. And, I stood with my dear roommate Lori and we watched those people jump. And the buildings fall. And the streets fill with sirens and then with dump trucks to be filled with dust. It was warm and our window unit brought in with it a frothy, terrible smell of burn. So much that we turned the unit off and then we slept together in one bed that night. The smoke overtook the sky and it darkened.
As I went up and down from the roof mere blocks away from this life-changing event—snapping photo after photo, unaware of ferocity and being a 24-year-old silly thing with no idea of how my life would change because of you—well, you changed.
And everything and everyone around you changed.
And we—all of us—are a very big, yet small population that woke up the next morning numb. But I suspect it hit us all at different points. Some that afternoon when a call never came. Some the day after that, finally allowed above Union Square and milling around a bar full of finance guys wearing suits, drunk off their heads and speaking quietly about having attended 7 funerals that day. Some the first time entering a plane again. Others when feeling the big tall skyscrapers move in the wind. Some in our dreams that repeat and repeat falling buildings. For some… it is just part of our life now.
I am scarred from what happened to you that day. I didn’t die. I didn’t go to NYSC at the World Trade Center that morning. I didn’t know a single person who died. I didn’t get covered in dust or have to crawl out of a fire-ridden staircase. I just watched it from a very near little space on Houston Street.
And I wish I’d have been looking another direction.